Promotions are powerful tools for driving conversions, boosting sales, and encouraging customer loyalty in eCommerce. However, many brands struggle with multiple challenges that prevent their promotions from delivering the desired results; from low conversion rates to discount abuse and margin erosion, these hurdles can significantly impact revenue and customer engagement.
In this guide, we’ll explore the most common pitfalls in eCommerce promotion and provide practical strategies for overcoming them. Whether you're dealing with cart abandonment, promo code misuse, or ineffective targeting, these actionable solutions will help you refine your promotion strategy for better outcomes.
1. Poor Promotion Performance & Low Conversion Rates
The Challenge
Let’s say you’ve launched a discount campaign, expecting an increase in sales, but the results are underwhelming. Promotions that are too generic often fail to resonate with customers, leading to low conversion rates. Even when shoppers apply a promo code, they may still abandon their carts before completing the purchase.
The Fix
Promotions should feel personalised and relevant to boost conversions. Instead of offering broad discounts to everyone, tailor promotions based on customer behaviour, purchase history, or engagement level. A/B testing can help determine which incentives perform best, such as a percentage discount, free shipping, or a gift with purchase.
Another idea is to create urgency with limited-time offers or countdown timers that encourage customers to act fast and result in better conversion rates.
📌 The average conversion rate across all eCommerce sites is under 2%, meaning most traffic doesn’t result in a purchase. Personalised promotions can help turn more browsers into buyers.1
📌 84% of consumers are likelier to shop with brands that offer personalised experiences.2
🔗 Read more: How to create a promo code campaign that delivers the ROI you need.
2. Promo Code Misuse & Discount Abuse
The Challenge
Discount abuse can severely impact profitability. Publicly shared promo codes lead to unintended discounts, while some customers manipulate promotions by stacking multiple codes or using them across different regions. This creates a financial strain and diminishes the exclusivity of your offers.
The Fix
To prevent promo code misuse, brands should use single-use, unique codes that expire after redemption. Restricting codes to specific customer segments or geographies ensures they are used as intended.
Brands can integrate secure promotion platforms, like Uniqodo, to track and control promo code distribution, reducing the risk of unauthorised use.
📌 Losing control of promotions is not uncommon, with 42% of businesses admitting that it has happened to them.3
🔗 Learn more: Preventing Promo Code Abuse: An eCommerce Guide
3. Cart Abandonment Despite Discounts
The Challenge
Even after applying a discount, many shoppers still abandon their carts. Unexpected shipping costs, a complicated checkout process, or second-guessing their purchase can lead them to leave before completing their order.
The Fix
Reducing friction in the checkout process is key to increasing conversions. One effective strategy is offering free shipping alongside promotions—customers are more likely to complete a purchase when they feel they’re getting extra value.
Exit-intent pop-ups providing an additional discount or bonus can also help retain hesitant shoppers.
Finally, ensuring that promo codes are automatically applied at checkout can eliminate unnecessary steps that cause drop-off.
📌 The average online shopping cart abandonment rate is 69.8%.4
📌 49% of consumers say they’re more likely to shop online when free shipping is offered.5
🔗 Related read: How retailers can use promo codes to target shopping cart abandonment
4. Over-Discounting & Margin Erosion
The Challenge
Relying too heavily on discounts can train customers to only shop when promotions are active, reducing long-term profitability. Offering excessive discounts also eats into margins, making it difficult for businesses to sustain revenue growth.
The Fix
Instead of offering deep, across-the-board discounts, brands should implement conditional promotions that drive higher spend. Tiered discounts (e.g., Buy 2, Get 10% Off; Buy 3, Get 15% Off) encourage higher spending.
Additionally, focusing on exclusive discounts for loyal customers rather than mass discounts ensures you’re rewarding the right audience without sacrificing profit.
📌 Tiered promotions increased average basket value by up to 30%.6
🔗 Learn more: The 6 Types of Promotions: BOGO vs Half-Off vs Conditional
5. Lack of Measurable ROI on Promotions
The Challenge
Many brands struggle to determine whether their promotions are actually driving new revenue or simply discounting purchases that would have happened anyway. Without clear tracking, it’s difficult to measure promotional ROI.
The Fix
Tracking promo codes and integrating analytics tools are essential for measuring campaign effectiveness. Brands should align promotions with specific business objectives, such as increasing AOV, acquiring new customers, or boosting retention.
Real-time analytics can help brands adjust their strategies dynamically to ensure the highest return on investment.
📌 47% of marketers struggle to measure ROI across multiple channels, making attribution a key concern.7
🔗 Related read: How to Increase Marketing ROI with Promo Codes
To conclude our guide
Promotions are an invaluable tool for eCommerce success, but without the right strategy, they can lead to revenue loss, customer disengagement, and operational challenges. By addressing these common hurdles—ranging from promo code misuse to ineffective targeting—brands can ensure that their promotions drive meaningful, sustainable growth.
Looking to optimise your promotions with a data-driven approach? Discover how Uniqodo can help you overcome these challenges and boost your campaign performance.
.png?width=2724&height=858&name=Frame%202246%20(1).png)
References
1. https://www.hubspot.com/marketing-statistics
2. https://www.theb2bhouse.com/e-commerce-statistics-trends-and-insights/
3. https://kount.com/en-gb/node/74#:~:text=Promo%20code%20abuse%20leads%20to%20poor%20user%20retention&text=Spend%20a%20dollar%20to%20give,no%20return%20on%20customer%20retention
4. https://www.theb2bhouse.com/e-commerce-statistics-trends-and-insights/
5. https://www.theb2bhouse.com/e-commerce-statistics-trends-and-insights/
6. https://www.bigcommerce.co.uk/blog/promotional-marketing/
7. https://firework.com/blog/marketing-roi-statistics
Subscribe to the Blog